Quantcast
Channel: nature.com blogs
Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 10

Too much of a good thing?

$
0
0

From Wilson et al.

We published another double header yesterday, this time on the role of particular cell types in visual responses. Both studies describe the effect of optogenetically manipulating various interneuron classes in mouse visual cortex. The papers are Lee et al. from Yang Dan‘s lab and Wilson et al. from Mriganka Sur‘s labs. And in fact, both were preceded by Atallah et al. from Massimo Scanziani’s lab, which appeared in Neuron earlier this year. Which means a bonanza of data on the effects of activating parvalbumin-expressing interneurons, and also a bonanza of different conclusions about their exact role – everyone comes to slightly different conclusions.

We’ve discussed joint (and triple) publication a number of times already on this blog, including situations where findings diverge. We even just recently discussed a triple publication involving a paper from Yang Dan’s lab. So I’ll leave it to you to extrapolate the editorial discussions that likely took place in this case, but if anyone wants to know more, leave a comment. Instead, I’ll touch on another question that we get asked fairly regularly: what do we do when authors submit papers to us in quick succession? Is there a limit on how many papers from one lab we will publish per year? Since we’re mentioning today a paper by an author who had a paper covered in the previous blog post, you can infer that number is at least two. Just kidding. Of course we have no limit. Scientific progress unfolds at different rates, and sometimes labs have some very good years. As long as a study has potential impact, we are happy to consider.

 

It’s Friday night now over here, so I’ll leave it at that. But to give you an idea of how much (or little) people publish with us more than once a year, here are wordles showing authors of our neuroscience papers in recent years. As it turns out, an imperfect way of displaying the data (it clearly highlights the general need for a means of disambiguating names in science!) but enjoy anyway (click on images to enlarge).

2007
2008
2009
2010
2011

Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 10

Latest Images

Trending Articles





Latest Images